Digiday reported on 2 November 2026 that Google search, long the ad line item buyers never questioned, is now under review. Agencies quoted in the piece say clients are looking at moving 10% to 30% of their Google search budgets to Meta, TikTok and Google’s own Local Services Ads.
The numbers from the article:
- Google Search ad revenue last year: US$114.2 billion, 38.8% of US digital ad spend.
- Search ad revenue growth in Q3 2026: 12%, the slowest quarter this year.
- Cost per click in Q3: up 5% on both branded and non-branded terms, per Tinuiti.
- Budget being questioned: about 10% now, rising to 20% to 30% through the holiday season, per Accuracast.
- Facebook ad spend among Tinuiti clients in Q3: up 16%.
Source: Digiday, 2 November 2026.
What the buyers are actually reacting to
The headline reading is that Google is losing its grip and the money is moving. That is not wrong, but it skips the cause an operator needs.
The buyers did not stop wanting to be found on Google. What changed is the return on the click. AI Overviews answer the query on the results page, so fewer people click through, while cost per click keeps rising. The agencies quoted say the ROI from Google “has been squeezed in recent years”. The line item lost its free pass because the thing it bought, a visit, is worth less and costs more.
People still ask which clinic to book or which software to install, on Google and increasingly on ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. The answer now sits on the page instead of behind a click.
Ranking is dead. Being named is the outcome.
SEO isn’t dead. It has evolved into GEO. What is dead is ranking as the goal.
My agency’s numbers make the point. On stridec.com, non-branded queries where we sat in positions one to three got a 0.08% click-through rate between June and August 2026. Branded queries got 27%. Being first on the page for a generic question earned almost nothing. Being the name someone already had in mind earned the visit. The click follows the name, and the name is now decided inside the answer.
The Digiday buyers are seeing the same collapse on the paid side.
What this looks like for an operator
Take a clinic or a small shop that has run Google Ads for years. The monthly report shows impressions holding, clicks drifting down and cost per click creeping up. The instinct is to cut 10% or 20% and push it to Meta.
That may be fine, but it leaves one question unanswered: when someone asks an engine “which physio near Tanjong Pagar is good for runners”, does the answer name you? If not, no budget shuffle fixes that. Meta spend buys attention earlier, not a place in the answer.
A business can sit on page one and still be absent from every AI answer. I learned that with AeroChat in August 2026, when it ranked third on Google for “best Shopify chatbot” but was not named in the AI Overview. Only one source on the list named us. The engine had nothing to quote.
What I did with the money
AeroChat is bootstrapped. We tried ads and at one point paid US$53 for every install. So we stopped trying to outrank the leaders and asked how to get the AI to see us as one of the options. We wrote down exactly what AeroChat is, who it is for and how it is different, and built pages around the questions that produced an AI answer. Within three weeks it was in the same answer box as Tidio, Gorgias and Intercom.
That is what the budget should buy now: being named, across every engine that answers the question.
What a business should do
- Pull the last three months of Google Ads and Search Console data. Separate branded from non-branded. If non-branded clicks are falling while positions hold, the position is worth less than the invoice says.
- Take the ten questions customers ask before they buy. Put each one to Google’s AI Overview, AI Mode, ChatGPT and Gemini. Record whether you are named, and the date.
- Where you are not named, fix the information first. Write one page that states plainly what you are, who you are for and what is different, with specifics an engine can quote. Then get the same facts onto pages you do not own.
- Only then decide how much of the Google line to move. Judge the ad spend on what happens after the click.
- Keep the SEO groundwork: the site still has to be indexable, fast and clear. The target is now the name in the answer, across every engine, not the position on one page.
Source: Digiday: Google search loses its free pass with buyers